Lesson Plan

Selling Murder

Critically watch a film that promotes to a broad audience the sterilization and so-called mercy killing of non-Aryans by the Nazi regime.

View All Lessons
Domain
The Holocaust
Subject
Final Solution
Topic
Euthanasia

Enduring Understanding

To pursue what the Nazis considered a “pure race of Aryans”, the Third Reich used medical techniques to sterilize and kill those they deemed undesirable.

Essential Question

  • 1What is the rationale that leads to an acceptance of using medicine for harm?

Readiness

10 Min
Teacher's Note
This lesson will address both the T4 euthanasia program and the use of propaganda to convince the public of the need for these murderous measures. So we recommend students are familiar with one subject or another in order to fully benefit from this lesson.

Review the concepts of euthanasia and propaganda and allude to the fact that mercy killings had to be sold to the public in order for there not to be widespread resistance. Before initiating conversation about the video, be sure to clarify relevant terms. Other concepts that are important here include Darwinism and heredity.

Input

25 Min

Watch the first 13 minutes of the video, The Killing Films of the Third Reich. Prepare to stop at various sections to discuss and contemplate the content.

  1. Begin by watching the section from 2:15-5:15 which gives a background to the role of propaganda in promoting the need for euthanasia. Pause for a reflection–written or verbal discussion–on the following questions:
    1. Ask your students to consider the phrase ‘life unworthy of life.’ What does this mean? How could this be possible? Do they see anyone portrayed this way in today’s world?
    2. The first two films called ‘What You Inherit’ and ‘Hereditarily Ill’ set the stage for the conversation. What does it mean to be ‘hereditarily ill’? Can one recover from such illness?
    3. Notice that the ‘hereditary diseases’ are also held against people who have fallen on hard times. What does this say about the science that backs up the discrimination?
  2. Continue from 5:15 – 8:50
    1. Why were these films ‘required’ to be seen by audiences across Germany?
    2. What do you think about the idea that human life should be dictated by nature exclusively?
    3. What is a ‘genetic threat’? What is ‘sterilization’?
  3. Continue again from 8:50 – 13:05
    1. Why do they use the image of a professor or doctor in their propaganda videos?
    2. Hitler ordered the killing of individuals after the war started. Why?
    3. Have you ever heard of any other victims of the Holocaust who were gassed?
    4. Why was evidence destroyed and fictional death reports created?

Output

20 Min

Now, ask students to generate their own responses to the video. Ask them to write about:

  1. What was the most astonishing fact about the video?
  2. What section would they like to go back and watch again?
  3. What questions do they still have about this era of Nazism?

Then, bring the discussion back to a large group and use student answers to have a large discussion/review sections of the video.

Teacher Primer

Know Before You Go

Before you teach, use our teacher primer to freshen up on your content knowledge.

Lesson Plan

Pseudoscience

Students will learn the history of antisemitism and how it was transformed into Nazi racial antisemitism through the years.

View All Lessons
Domain
Intolerance
Subject
Antisemitism
Topic
Racism

Enduring Understanding

Antisemitism was not invented with the rise of the Nazi party. It had deep roots that were transformed to fit the racist ideology of the time.

Essential Question

  • 1How can we be sure that what we're learning is accurate?

Readiness

5 Min

Begin by prompting your students to think about forms of intolerance. What kind of ‘isms’ can they think of that separate one group from another in a detrimental way?

Do they believe that certain ‘isms’ are more powerful than others? Why might this be?

Input

25 Min

This lesson can be found in an expanded form here.
Divide students into groups or pairs.
Distribute the first definition card within this three page bundle, which defines the terms ideology, racists and ethnicity.
In groups, pairs, or individually students work to define the yellow highlighted words. After the group defines the word, they use dictionaries to check their definitions.
After 5 minutes come together and have students briefly share:

  1. How their definitions of highlighted words were similar/different to the dictionary.
  2. If defining the highlighted words increased their understanding of the definitions of ideology, racists, and race.

Pivot toward the question of pseudoscience: Now that we have definitions of racists and race, let’s examine the pseudo science behind beliefs that human behavior is biologically determined. See if they know what pseudo means.

Distribute and read definition cards two and three which defines pseudo, science and racial antisemitism.
–> Students can repeat the definitional activity used with the first definition cards for the second and third cards as well..
Check for understanding of the concept of pseudoscience and racial antisemitism.
Answer questions or clear misconceptions before proceeding.

Output

20 Min

Watch this short clip from USHMM about racism in the Nazi party. Then ask students to respond to the following questions either in writing or small groups before opening up for a large group discussion. You may also assign certain questions to groups or individuals to reduce the time for responses.

  1. At the beginning of the video, the narrator remarks that the Nazis “wanted to create a racially pure Germany”. What about this statement is already a red flag, given what you know about race?
  2. During the Nazi era, racial science was taught in schools, and this helped create a youth that was complicit with the racism that Nazi’s were promoting. Why were such violent biases taught to young people in school?
  3. Sometimes people claim something as “scientific” to make it sound legitimate, even if it is patently false. Why is the legitimizing stamp of science so important?
  4. How can racism help keep a party or political group in power?
  5. Despite overwhelming scientific data to the contrary, many people still believe in the superiority of certain races. Why might individuals hold onto a belief that has been discredited because it’s not factually true? How might they change their minds?
  6. What information do racists use to justify their beliefs? How can radical beliefs, like these, be challenged and countered?
Teacher Primer

Know Before You Go

Before you teach, use our teacher primer to freshen up on your content knowledge.

Lesson Plan

Dreyfus Accused

Read through a translation of the famous text J’Accuse! and answer questions based off of the text. Students will learn about bias, perspective, and the construction of history.

View All Lessons
Domain
Intolerance
Subject
Antisemitism
Topic
Racism

Enduring Understanding

Antisemitic racism was alive and well in Europe well before the Nazis came to power.

Essential Questions

  • 1How does racism affect situations that should otherwise be fair?
  • 2What impact do biases have on a person's ability to get a fair trial?

Readiness

5 Min

Provide students with a brief overview of the Dreyfus Affair. A presentation with important dates and facts can be found here. Go over this with your students if you feel it necessary and time permits.

In brief, explain to students that Alfred Dreyfus was accused of stealing military secrets with weak evidence and was sentenced to prison. Tell students that the document they will be reading is a newspaper article written by a Dreyfus supporter, Emile Zola, who accused the French military of a conspiracy against Dreyfus.

Input

20 Min

Read through the translation of J’Accuse! provided by the University of Pennsylvania Library as a class.

As you read together collectively, ask students to take notes utilizing the 3Ps Method; taking note of things they find a) Powerful b) Puzzling and c) Propelling.

Once you’ve finished reading, attempt to clarify the sections that students found puzzling.

In order to familiarize yourself, and your class with this model, please look over this guide: 3Ps: A Critical Reading Guide.

Output

25 Min

Divide students into pairs or groups of three before directing them to the Reading Road Map questions at the bottom of the reading. Give students approximately 10-15 minutes to jot down their answers.

After everyone has had a chance to write down their answers, go over the questions as a class. Finally, address the essential questions directly to the class and open up a class discussion on whether biases still exist in justice systems today.

Teacher Primer

Know Before You Go

Before you teach, use our teacher primer to freshen up on your content knowledge.

Lesson Plan

Mock Paris Peace Conference

Students will simulate the negotiations done during the Paris Peace Conference. This activity will help students to understand the challenge faced when negotiating terms after World War I.

View All Lessons

Enduring Understanding

The different players of the Paris Peace Conference all had their own agendas and ideas on repercussions.

Essential Question

  • 1Is it possible to negotiate terms that everyone can be pleased with?

Readiness

10 Min
Teacher's Note
Prior to this lesson students should have a general knowledge and understanding of World War I. If not, please go back to one of the lessons on WWI to prepare students for this lessons.

Open up the lesson with this simple activity: Imagine you have to split one pizza among four people. One person is gluten free, one is a vegetarian, one is allergic to olives, and the other LOVES meat. How do you compromise? What kind of pizza can you order that everyone could agree to?

You may want to draw a pizza on the board and have students raise their hands with options for crust and toppings.

Input

10 Min
Teacher's Note
Mock trials and simulations are appropriate for this topic as it does not place students in the role of victim or perpetrator. In other lessons on the Holocaust, we caution against using simulations and role play activities.

Explain to the class that they will be divided into three groups in order to simulate the negotiations for the Paris Peace Conference. This document will provide the three groups with the information they will need in order to speak on behalf of either France, Britain, or the United States.

Divide the class into three groups and assign them to be France, Britain, or the US. Ask the students to read the materials for their country to understand where they stand in the negotiations.

Output

40 Min

The worksheets that will be used below can be found on the Treaty of Versailles Simulation resource.

Provide students with the Options for Negotiation (page 4) so they are able to see what their options are during the negotiations.

It would be beneficial if you can arrange the classroom in a manner that would allow the three groups to converse openly during the negotiations, such as forming a giant circle with all chairs facing towards the center.

As the teacher you will be the one facilitating the negotiations. Using the Options for Negotiation (page 4), ask the first question to the class as a point for negotiation. You may not have time to go over every question so read them through and pick out which ones you find the most suited for your class. Provide students with the Negotiation Worksheet (page 5) to record the terms of agreement they were able to come up with.

Teacher Primer

Know Before You Go

Before you teach, use our teacher primer to freshen up on your content knowledge.

Lesson Plan

World Leaders Hesitate

Examine a detailed video about the international response to growing evidence of Nazi war crimes and learn about the effect that public pressure can have on the decisions of governments.

View All Lessons

Enduring Understanding

International leaders were slow to respond to the evidence of the mass murder of Jews by the Nazi regime.

Essential Question

  • 1Why are heads of state hesitant to intervene, even when there is evidence that atrocities are occurring?

Readiness

15 Min

Prompt students to do a bit of pre-writing about the subject. Ask them to reflect briefly on the motivations of the Allied forces of World War II. Specifically, prompt them to see if the likes of Great Britain, the USA and France were focused on stopping the Holocaust. After a few minutes, ask students to voice their answers and orient them to the predominantly political nature of the conflict.

Input

15 Min

Before showing the video, anticipate some of its content by asking students to pay close attention to the following questions:

  1. When was the information about the Holocaust revealed?
  2. Who received this information?
  3. What did the recipients of this information do with it?
  4. Did nations change their approach to war, in light of evidence about the Holocaust?
  5. What groups were responsible for initiating action?

Then, show the first 8:20 of the video, Did the world remain silent? produced by Tel Aviv University.

After the video, see if your students can answer the five questions listed above.

Output

20 Min

After establishing the facts around these international responses, split the class into three groups, each of whom will respond to a different troubling fact discussed in the video. Ask each group to tackle these questions in depth, thinking about the context of the situation as much as they can.

Group 1: At 1:42, the speaker suggests that the Russians saw evidence of the Holocaust in early 1942, but concealed the fact that murders were taking place specifically against Jews. Why?

Group 2: At 5:08 the speaker mentions that even at the end of 1942, ‘no concrete action’ to stop the Holocaust was mentioned by the Allies, despite mounting evidence of the murders. Why would the Allies not develop a plan to stop the atrocities?

Group 3: At 5:28, the speaker mentions that the War Refugee Board, which helped save the lives of thousands of Jews, was created as a result of public pressure. What does this say about your role as a citizen?

Teacher Primer

Know Before You Go

Before you teach, use our teacher primer to freshen up on your content knowledge.